The trial of Patrick Cooney, accused of the murder of Elijah Lewis during a road rage incident in Capitol Hill, began on January 15, 2025. Cooney, who has pleaded not guilty, asserts that he shot Lewis in self-defense while riding a Lime scooter. The confrontation escalated as Cooney felt threatened and opened fire, killing Lewis and injuring his young nephew. Much of the encounter was recorded on security video, raising alarms among Lewis’s family about potential biases in the legal proceedings, particularly after the judge limited the presentation of Cooney's past violent actions. Cooney's defense successfully argued to suppress evidence that could portray him as a recurring threat, including incidents where he brandished firearms in confrontational situations.

The case has garnered significant public attention due to Lewis's reputation as a community leader and activist, remembered for his contributions to local initiatives. As the trial unfolds, there are growing concerns that the judicial process may not deliver the justice that Lewis's family seeks. The case's outcome could have profound implications for perceptions of accountability in similar violent incidents.